A Critical Examination of the Relationship between Myth and Religion in Ernst Cassirer’s Philosophy of Symbolic Forms and Its Implications for the Philosophy of Religion

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 Master's degree in Philosophy of Religion, Kharazmi University

2 Associate Professor of Philosophy of Religion, Kharazmi University, Tehran, Iran

Abstract
Extended abstract
Ernst Cassirer’s philosophy of symbolic forms is one of the most ambitious twentieth-century attempts to explain human culture without reducing its plurality to a single model of knowledge. A symbolic form is not a decorative sign placed over a ready-made reality; it is an active, historically embodied way in which experience is organized, objectified, and made shareable. Language, myth, religion, art, and science accordingly disclose different dimensions of a human world. Within this system, however, the status of religion remains ambiguous. Cassirer frequently discusses myth and religion together as mythical-religious consciousness, which encourages the view that religion is merely a developed continuation of myth. The present review article re-examines that assumption. Its central claim is that the relation is best reconstructed as continuity in origin together with rupture in structure. Religion preserves myth’s affective and symbolic resources, yet reorganizes their mode of reference, conception of the sacred, and understanding of agency and responsibility.
The study employs critical reconstruction. First, it identifies Cassirer’s principal claims about symbolic mediation, mythical logic, and the development of religion in his major works. Second, it reconstructs arguments that are often dispersed rather than formally stated in those texts. Third, it tests the reconstructed position against contemporary interpretations and objections. This procedure also distinguishes Cassirer’s own terminology from analytical concepts introduced by the authors, including symbolic reductionism and functional encroachment. The aim is limited: the article asks what Cassirer’s framework can clarify in philosophy of religion, not whether it can replace metaphysics, theology, empirical anthropology, or political theory.
Cassirer treats myth as an autonomous organization of experience, not as a defective scientific explanation. Its primary material is affect: fear, hope, wonder, dependence, and a sympathetic participation in surrounding life. Myth converts affect into public images, narratives, names, and rites. Its logic is expressed through the relative identity of sign and signified and of part and whole. A name, image, relic, or bodily fragment can therefore participate in the power of what it signifies. The same orientation shapes the central categories of myth. The sacred-profane opposition gives experience an affective and evaluative tonality; causality appears through contiguity, resemblance, and participation; space is heterogeneous and divided into privileged regions; time is qualitative, cyclical, and ritually repeatable; and number bears qualitative powers rather than merely measuring quantity. These features form a coherent symbolic world while still allowing ordinary, non-sacred practices to coexist with mythical ones.
Religion continues myth because both emerge from symbolically articulated affect, ritual, narrative, and the distinction between sacred and profane. The decisive rupture begins when magical attempts to manipulate sacred forces prove inadequate and the sacred can no longer be treated merely as an impersonal power such as mana. Cassirer’s developmental account moves from momentary and functional gods toward personal gods who possess enduring identity and will. The divine becomes a ‘Thou’ who addresses the human person and calls for response. Correspondingly, human individuality is no longer dissolved in the tribe or totem but is constituted through accountability, promise, repentance, and ethical obligation. The transformation of sacrifice from magical exchange toward justice, self-giving, and moral holiness makes this break especially visible. Mysticism intensifies the tension between finite and infinite, but it does not eliminate mediation altogether: once communicated within a tradition, mystical experience still requires metaphor, narrative, poetry, ritual, or disciplined silence.
In religious language, Cassirer undermines the positivist assumption that empirical verification exhausts meaning. Religious discourse is intelligible within an intersubjective network of narrative, prayer, ritual, ethical command, and experience; nevertheless, cultural objectivity does not by itself prove that a transcendent referent exists independently of culture. In science and religion, the theory identifies many conflicts as functional encroachments: science properly investigates measurable, causal relations, whereas religion articulates existential orientation, value, and the sacred. The creation-evolution debate illustrates the point. Evolutionary biology retains full authority over empirical claims about the history and diversification of life, while a creation narrative may organize qualitative time, purpose, and responsibility. Yet genuinely empirical religious assertions remain answerable to evidence, so symbolic interpretation cannot become an ad hoc device for immunizing belief. In religion and politics, Cassirer’s analysis of modern political myth shows how language, ritual, prophecy, and leader worship can sacralize worldly power. Ethical religion may resist this regression by protecting individuality and responsibility, but democratic legitimacy additionally requires equal rights, rule of law, freedom of conscience, and public criticism.
Cassirer’s account has important limits. It provides no sufficient inter-form criteria for deciding between incompatible religious truth claims; it describes the semantic possibility of transition from magic to ethical religion without fully explaining its historical causes; and its transcendental method leaves the independent reality of God and revelation methodologically undecided. Its developmental vocabulary also bears traces of early twentieth-century evolutionism, while its hierarchy of expression, representation, and pure meaning can covertly privilege scientific rationality. Politically, Cassirer underestimates the roles of instrumental reason, bureaucracy, economy, media, and technology in modern domination and treats political myth too uniformly as pathological. These objections define the theory’s defensible scope. Cassirer is most useful not as a complete theology, theory of truth, or political philosophy, but as a critical grammar of culture: a framework for identifying modes of symbolization, exposing category mistakes, and resisting the reduction of every form of meaning to the standards of a single domain.

Keywords


Ayer, A. J. (1952). Language, Truth and Logic, 2nd ed., New York: Dover Publications.
Blackford, Russell (2000). “Stephen Jay Gould on Science and Religion”, Quadrant 44 (4): 8–14.
Blind, Georg D.; & Steineck, Raji (2021). “The Missing Piece in E. Cassirer’s Theory of Symbolic Forms: The Economy”, Evolutionary and Institutional Economics Review 18: 291–315, doi: 10.1007/s40844-020-00191-0.
Bottici, Chiara (2007). A Philosophy of Political Myth, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, doi: 10.1017/CBO9780511498626.
Capeillères, Fabien (2015). “Cassirer on the ‘Objectity’ of Evil: The Symbolic Constitution of Der Mythus des 20. Jahrhunderts”, in: The Philosophy of Ernst Cassirer: A Novel Assessment, ed. by: J. Tyler Friedman and Sebastian Luft, 435–468, Berlin and Boston: De Gruyter, doi: 10.1515/9783110421811-019.
Cassirer, Ernst (1923). Substance and Function and Einstein’s Theory of Relativity, trans. by: William Curtis Swabey and Marie Collins Swabey, Chicago: Open Court.
Cassirer, Ernst (1944). An Essay on Man: An Introduction to a Philosophy of Human Culture, New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Cassirer, Ernst (1946). The Myth of the State, New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Cassirer, Ernst (1951). The Philosophy of the Enlightenment, trans. by: Fritz C. A. Koelln and James P. Pettegrove, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Cassirer, Ernst (1955). The Philosophy of Symbolic Forms, Vol. 2, Mythical Thought, trans. by: Ralph Manheim, New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Cassirer, Ernst (1957). The Philosophy of Symbolic Forms. Vol. 3, The Phenomenology of Knowledge, trans. by: Ralph Manheim, New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Cassirer, Ernst (1981). Philosophy and Culture, trans. by: Bozorg Naderzad, Tehran: Mo’asseseh-ye Motale‘at va Tahqiqat-e Farhangi. [In Persian]
Cassirer, Ernst (1996). The Philosophy of Symbolic Forms. Vol. 4, The Metaphysics of Symbolic Forms, trans. by: John Michael Krois, New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Cassirer, Ernst (2020a). The Myth of the State, trans. by: Yadollah Moqen, Tehran: Hermes. [In Persian]
Cassirer, Ernst (2020b). The Philosophy of Symbolic Forms. Vol. 2, Mythical Thought, trans. by: Yadollah Moqen, Tehran: Hermes. [In Persian]
Cassirer, Ernst (2021). Language and Myth, trans. by: Mohsen Salasi, Tehran: Morvarid. [In Persian]
Codrington, R. H. (1891). The Melanesians: Studies in Their Anthropology and Folk-Lore, Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Coskun, Deniz (2007). “The Politics of Myth: Ernst Cassirer’s Pathology of the Totalitarian State”, in: Law as Symbolic Form: Ernst Cassirer and the Anthropocentric View of Law, 135–172, Dordrecht: Springer, doi: 10.1007/978-1-4020-6256-8_4.
Eliade, Mircea (2022). The Sacred and the Profane, trans. by: Nasrollah Zangouei, Tehran: Soroush. [In Persian]
Esparza, Gustavo Adolfo (2024). “The Perception of the Divine: Myth, Art, and Religion in Ernst Cassirer”, Filozofia 79 (8): 921–934, doi:10.31577/filozofia.2024.79.8.6.
Ferrari, Massimo (2021). “Science as a Symbolic Form: Ernst Cassirer’s Culture of Reason”, in: Interpreting Cassirer: Critical Essays, ed. by: Simon Truwant, 72–88, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, doi: 10.1017/9781108677806.006.
Friedman, Michael (2000). A Parting of the Ways: Carnap, Cassirer, and Heidegger, Chicago: Open Court.
Gordon, Peter E. (2010). Continental Divide: Heidegger, Cassirer, Davos. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Gould, Stephen Jay (1999). “Non-Overlapping Magisteria”, Skeptical Inquirer 23 (4): 55–61.
Hegel, G. W. F. (1977). Phenomenology of Spirit, trans. by: A. V. Miller, Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Horkheimer, Max; & Adorno, Theodor W. (2002). Dialectic of Enlightenment: Philosophical Fragments, ed. by: Gunzelin Schmid Noerr, trans. by: Edmund Jephcott, Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
Jafari, Hassan (2010). “Religion and Myth: An Examination of Ernst Cassirer’s Theory of Myth”, Pazhoheshnameh-ye Adyan 3 (6): 27–54. [In Persian]
Kant, Immanuel (1998). Critique of Pure Reason, trans. and ed. by: Paul Guyer and Allen W. Wood, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Kinzel, Katherina (2024). “Unifying Themes and Irresolvable Tensions in Cassirer’s System of Symbolic Forms”, British Journal for the History of Philosophy 32 (5): 1173–1181. doi: 10.1080/09608788.2023.2239024.
Kolshus, Thorgeir (2013). “Codrington, Keesing, and Central Melanesian Mana: Two Historic Trajectories of Polynesian Cultural Dissemination”, Oceania 83 (3): 316–327, doi: 10.1002/ocea.5027.
Kreis, Guido (2023). “Cassirer’s Concept of a Symbolic Form Reconsidered”, European Journal of Philosophy 31 (4): 1115–1124, doi:10.1111/ejop.12912.
Krois, John Michael (1987). Cassirer: Symbolic Forms and History, New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Luft, Sebastian (2005). “Cassirer’s Philosophy of Symbolic Forms: Between Reason and Relativism; A Critical Appraisal”, Idealistic Studies 34 (1): 25–47.
Luft, Sebastian (2015). The Space of Culture: Towards a Neo-Kantian Philosophy of Culture—Cohen, Natorp, and Cassirer, Oxford: Oxford University Press, doi: 10.1093/acprof:oso/9780198738848.001.0001.
Matherne, Samantha (2021). Cassirer, Abingdon, Oxon, and New York: Routledge.
Moghanipour, Majid Reza; & Rahmani, Ashkan (2021). “The Layering of the Cognitive Apparatus of Mythical Consciousness from the Perspective of Ernst Cassirer, based on the Characteristics of Stability, Fundamentality, and Extent of Influence”, Journal of Epistemological Research 9 (20): 145–164. [In Persian]
Moghanipour, Majid Reza (2021). “The Study of the Nature of Mythical Space in Ernst Cassirer’s Views”, Metaphysics 12 (30): 101–119, https://doi.org/10.22108/mph.2021.124505.1240. [In Persian]
Moghanipour, Majid Reza (2022). “The Study of the Nature, Function, and Embodiment of Number in Mythical Consciousness from the Perspective of Ernst Cassirer”, Philosophical Investigations 16 (38): 745–767, https://doi.org/10.22034/jpiut.2021.48743.3033. [In Persian]
Moss, Gregory S. (2022). “The Place of the Sacred in Cassirer’s Philosophy of Mythology”, Studia Kantiana 20 (2): 221–234, doi: 10.5380/sk.v20i2.90649.
Renz, Ursula (2011). “From Philosophy to Criticism of Myth: Cassirer’s Concept of Myth”, Synthese 179 (1): 135–152, doi: 10.1007/s11229-009-9624-7.
Schwartz, Yossef (2008). “Ernst Cassirer on Nicholas of Cusa: Between Conjectural Knowledge and Religious Pluralism”, in: The Symbolic Construction of Reality: The Legacy of Ernst Cassirer, ed. by: Jeffrey Andrew Barash, 17–39. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, doi: 10.7208/chicago/9780226036892.003.0002.
Truwant, Simon (2022). Cassirer and Heidegger in Davos: The Philosophical Arguments, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, doi: 10.1017/9781009019569.
Urban, Wilbur Marshall (1949). “Cassirer’s Philosophy of Language”, in: The Philosophy of Ernst Cassirer, ed. by: Paul Arthur Schilpp, 401–442, Evanston, IL: Library of Living Philosophers.
Verene, Donald Phillip (2008). “Cassirer’s Metaphysics”, in: The Symbolic Construction of Reality: The Legacy of Ernst Cassirer, ed. by: Jeffrey Andrew Barash, 93–103, Chicago: University of Chicago Press, doi: 10.7208/chicago/9780226036892.003.0005.