A Critical Analysis of the Multiverse Hypothesis versus the Fine-Tuning Argument from the Perspective of Imam Philosophical Theology

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 University Tabrize

2 Tabriz University

Abstract
"In contemporary cosmology, the 'Fine-Tuning Argument,' due to the astonishing precision of fundamental constants for the emergence of life, provides evidence for the existence of a conscious Designer. Conversely, modern atheism, seeking to evade teleology, proposes the 'Parallel Universes' (Multiverse) hypothesis as an alternative explanation to reduce cosmic order to a mere probabilistic accident. The aim of this research is to critically analyze this confrontation from the perspective of Imami philosophical theology. Drawing upon the principles of 'Final Cause' and 'Immateriality' (Tajarrud), the author argues that the multiverse hypothesis is not only empirically unverifiable but also shifts the problem of design to a higher level and cannot serve as a substitute for the First Cause. The results indicate that the multiplicity of universes, rather than negating the Designer, testifies to the extensiveness of Divine power and wisdom; thus, the probabilistic explanations of modern atheism represent a cessation in the face of existential complexities, rather than a genuine answer to them."

Keywords